Taster Membership

Policy Update February 2014 - NHS 'care.data' Project

Tom Smith, BSG Chief Executive

On the 18th February, and following a lot of media pressure, NHS England were forced to announce that they would delay the introduction of the 'care.data project' admitting they had not done enough to explain the scheme to the public. NHS England promised that it would soon be launching a "very exciting" programme designed to better communicate the purpose and benefits of the data-sharing scheme. For the long-term benefit of the NHS, we should hope this step-change is meaningful and successful.

Phil Booth, of the campaign group MedConfidential, was one of many who were pleased by the decision to pause care.data. He said, "Finally officials at NHS England have seen reason. To upload millions of patients' confidential data without providing full and proper information or seeking consent would have been the largest breach of confidence in NHS history."

Several problems came to light. The public were not aware their data was being uploaded. There were concerns that private information would be accessed. There were fears from some that the private sector would purchase the data, something that was reinforced by a Telegraph report that an agency linked to the insurance industry had previously bought data, though they failed to explain that the data was aggregate and not individual. NHS England said this would not happen now and that decision was made prior to its creation. Not many people will have been reassured and NHS England now have a lot of work to do to increase confidence in its ability to handle data.

The row partly became political because of concerns the government were not seeking to explain the scheme to people and because there are proposals to share the data with NHS partners some of whom are private companies. Some of these companies provide analytical services to the NHS, supporting commissioning and there is a fear that they will use access to the data to grow other aspects of their business. In The Times, Hugo Rifkind noted that discussion over medical information was becoming another battlefront for an ideological discussion of whether the NHS is being privatised. "This is blinkered nonsense at the best of times, and particularly so here. For one thing, Care.data is a medical project, not a political one, and your 'Tories want to sell the NHS' antenna has to be set to a ragingly high paranoia rating not to realise this."

The basic problem has been a failure to demonstrate that systems are in place to answer public concerns. As Labour health spokesman Jamie Reed said: "This is another NHS shambles of this Government's own making. Along with health professionals, we raised concerns about the security of the data to be shared. Patients need to be assured that their records will be genuinely anonymous and that they have had the opportunity to opt out." Both the BMA and Royal College of General Practitioners have warned that patients have been kept in the dark about plans.

When the Health Select Committee asked NHS England officials for the plans that had been made to handle the project they found that no code of conduct had been drawn up for the implementation of care.data even though one should have been drawn up under the terms of the 2012 Health Act.

A good idea, collecting information to better inform clinical management is a good idea but the apparent lack of preparation risks jeopardising an important project. This view was best expressed by Sharmila Nebhrajani, the new chief executive of the Association of Medical Research Charities, who said care.data was a good idea in principle that had been "stymied by its execution". She said: "Charities and their supporting patient groups have always said that sharing data for research can be a really valuable opportunity to speed medical research but it must be done with care, competence and consent."

The Financial Times was irritated by the debate and expressed concern that that those encouraging a backlash against NHS plans may do patients a mis-service. They note fears that the state could know too much about people and that the public is being encouraged to revolt. 'But what about the opposite dystopia? Powerless patients forced to take what they are given by a state that is ignorant of what works best. The tyranny of not knowing.'

Over the next six months care must be taken to explain the benefits of collecting large data sets while pointing patients to the safeguards that exist. As a GI community we have a responsibility to help explain the benefits of having large data sets with meaningful clinical information. Important initiatives like the IBD Registry could be stymied be a backlash against the centralisation of data (though the public may have more faith in a patient-professional partnership holding the data than in NHS England).

The IBD Registry will provide local, regional and national perspectives in order to better define the pattern of IBD and as a resource to help advance understanding of and response to the condition. The Registry will enable researchers to access up-to-date real time information about services, patient characteristics, the natural history of the condition, and drug treatments and their outcomes.

As well as national gains there are significant local advantages in collecting data locally. At Luton and Dunstable Matthew Johnson and colleagues are using the additional data to change the way they care for patients. They have set up virtual clinics offering telephone advice and support, freeing up slots in the hospital, providing greater access and helping commissioners to save money by reorganising services. They have been shortlisted by the BMJ for Gastroenterology Team of the year!

The Registry provides a vehicle for easily collecting and using real time clinical information to feed into a UK-wide data set and future IBD Audit. Collecting information will help to strengthen standards and provide a foundation for improving care for IBD patients. We should play our part both in explaining the benefits of central data collection and in encouraging NHS England to come up with the safeguards that will turn the tide of public debate in support of large-scale data analysis.

Taster Members Login

Please enter your user id in the box below to access the taster member private area.

Video: Choosing a career in Gastro?

Editing Taster Membership Details

Access to Aptify...


your BSG membership database.


If you wish to see or update your membership record or change your password please click here.

Please note: The membership payment year runs from 1st January through to 31st December each year, therefore at any part of the year you join you will pay £15.00 and will pay a further £15.00 the following January for a whole year.

Video: Benefits of Taster Membership

Meet Your Committee...

Name: Dr Liam Morris

Position: Chair

Representing: North West

Grade: ST6

Interests: Medical Education, Medical Leadership, Endoscopy

Ask Liam a Question:

Gastroenterology is a very diverse speciality with a wide range of possible career pathways available. This diversity is what first attracted me to the speciality and my career aspirations have changed a lot in my 3 years of training so far. It is a field of medicine which is always changing due to advances in research, ensuring that you will never stop learning.

Name: Dr Ellie Taylor

Position: Secretary

Representing: Yorkshire & Humber



Ask Ellie a Question:


Name: Dr Louise China

Position: Former Chair

Representing: NE Thames

Grade: ST5 (OOPR)

Interests: Hepatology, Medical Education

I'm a Gastroenterology SpR currently undertaking a Hepatology research fellowship (3 years) and have just finished a year out as a clinical teaching fellow at UCL medical school. I chose Gastroenterology not only because of the variety, but also because of the people you get to work with - Gastroenterologists tend to be an intelligent, competitive and aspirational bunch who are good fun! The range of patients (age, condition & personality) and the practical side mean you'll never have a boring day at work. There's also many avenues other than clinical work you can explore within the specialty.

Ask Louise a Question:

Name: Dr Suranga Dharmasiri

Position: Treasurer

Representing: Wessex

Grade: ST5 (OOPR)

Interests: IBD, Clinical and basic science research

Ask Suranga a Question:

I am a gastroenterology trainee in the Wessex region. I was attracted to gastroenterology early in my career as it offered the opportunity to work in several different settings and work closely with other specialities. My training has confirmed that this was a great choice for me. The procedural elements and clinics ensure that you don't get ward fatigue, while caring for patients on the ward means you keep those emergency situation where the adrenalin gets pumping. I have a speciality interest in IBD and I am engaged in both clinical and basic science research in this area. I look forward to speaking to any future potential gastroenterologists.

Name: Dr Steve Dixon

Representing: Severn & South-West Peninsula

Grade: ST6 (OOPR)

Interests: All aspects of luminal gastroenterology, nutrition, endoscopy and gastrointestinal cancer

Ask Steve a Question:

I've been a gastroenterology trainee for five years and have developed an interest in all things gut-related. More recently I have become a clinical research fellow and am enjoying the challenges of gastrointestinal research. Always happy to take questions from people interested in this terrific discipline and the wonderful West of England.

Name: Dr Kesavan Kandiah

Representing: NW Thames

Grade: St7

Interests:Luminal gastroenterology with interest in advanced endoscopy

Ask Kesavan a Question:

I am a gastroenterology SpR in the NW Thames rotation, currently in OOPR in Queen Alexandra Hospital, Portsmouth. Finding a specialty that one would like to commit to for the rest of his/her life can be challenging. Gastroenterology was an easy choice for me. The case mix, the interdisciplinary team interaction and the technical skills required make this specialty a truly exciting one. I’m thoroughly enjoying my career in gastroenterology and am certain that i will continue to do so in the many years to come!

Name: Dr Sinan Al-Rubaye

Representing: Mersey



Ask Sinan a Question:


Name: Dr Hasan Haboubi

Representing: Wales

Grade: ST5

Interests: Oesophagology, Digestive Oncology

Ask Hasan a Question:

I'm an academic gastroenterology trainee in the Wales Deanery and have been completing a PhD in Swansea University. I'm passionate about medical education and tackling trainee issues.

Name: Dr Laura Kitto

Representing: East Scotland

Grade: St4

Interests: Hepatology, Research

Ask Laura a Question:

I'm currently working as a Clinical Lecturer in South East Scotland. Gastroenterology is a fascinating and varied specialty with a huge range of pathology, a great mix of acute and chronic conditions, exciting practical skills and lots of opportunities for research. I've thoroughly enjoyed my first year of training and would highly recommend the specialty.

Name: Dr Jennifer Clough

Representing: South Thames



Ask Jennifer a Question:


Name: Dr Philip Harvey

Representing: West Midlands

Grade: OOPR

Interests: Medical leadership, Healthcare Informatics, Luminal gastroenterology and Endoscopy/ERCP

Ask Philip a Question:

I'm currently doing an MD looking at endoscopy outcomes using large scale national databases. I chose gastro because it offers huge variety, practical skills, and working in a multi-skilled team. There is also nothing more rewarding than seeing that CBD stone come through the ampulla! I also believe good quality clinical leadership helps both patients and Doctors. Given the growth of IT infrastructure in healthcare, methodologically robust "big data" is the way to inform those leaders.

Name: Dr Rebecca Dunn

Representing: Northern

Grade: St5

Interests: Hepatology, Medical Education

Ask Rebecca a Question:


Name: Dr John McGoran

Representing: Northern Ireland

Grade: ST5

Interests: Teaching and training, oesophageal medicine, EUS

Ask John a Question:

I currently work and train in Northern Ireland, where I have got to know my fellow trainees extremely well and link regularly with colleagues south of the border. I chose gastroenterology as a specialty because of the variety, the practical nature of the work and most importantly the partnerships we form with our patients to co-manage many conditions. It's great fun and has a bright future. I'm very eager to hear from any budding gastroenterologists about any questions, issues or suggestions you might have.

Name: Dr Sharmila Subramaniam

Representing: NE Thames



Ask Sharmila a Question:


Name: Dr Emily Tucker

Representing: East Midlands



Ask Emily a Question:


Name: Dr Jennifer Veryan

Representing: West of Scotland

Grade: St5

Interests: IBD, medical education

Ask Jennifer a Question:


Name: Dr Michael Fitzpatrick

Representing: Oxford

Grade: ST6 (OOPR)

Interests: Coeliac disease, IBD, Nutrition

Ask Michael a Question:

I am a gastroenterology registrar currently out of programme in research, studying intestinal T cell responses in coeliac disease for a DPhil at the University of Oxford. I joined the BSG committee in 2017 and I also represent Thames Valley trainees at the Royal College of Physicians. Gastroenterology is a great career; it is a busy and challenging specialty, with great opportunities in research, teaching and service development, and most importantly we have a lot of fun doing the job!

Name: Dr Giovanna Sheiybani

Representing: CT1

Grade: CT1

Interests: Endoscopy/Hepatology and Medical Education

I am currently a Trust Grade in Stroke medicine and I am due to start Core Medical Training in the Peninsula Deanery. My enthusiasm to pursue Gastroenterology in the future stems from working with very enthusiastic and practical Consultants from my Foundation Years. My aim is to specialise in Endoscopy or Hepatology.
Being involved in various projects in Gastroenterology and presenting at the BSG conferences, I have been able to thrust myself into the challenges of the practical and academic aspects of this field. Working in this field is immensely rewarding, even as a junior, and the variety of endoscopy, outpatient and inpatient work is what interests me. I have a great interest in medical education and I am currently developing an undergraduate course in using drama to demonstrate the patient narrative and to use these skills to improve history-taking.

Ask Giovanna a Question: